A family of four in Mumbai’s Pydhonie area died in the early hours of April 26. Watermelon was blamed at first, but the story is more layered than that.
The family had earlier shared a biryani dinner with relatives at around 10:30 PM on April 25, and not one of those relatives fell ill.
It was only the four family members who ate watermelon later, at around 1 AM, who died, a detail that quietly but firmly shifted suspicion away from the food and towards something far more sinister.
On May 7, forensic experts confirmed it: traces of zinc phosphide, a highly toxic rat poison, were found in the viscera or the internal organs of the victims.
Police have said there is no evidence so far that the watermelon itself caused the deaths, and investigators are examining whether the poison was introduced deliberately, accidentally, or through contamination in the supply chain.
The victims have been identified as Abdullah Dokadia, his wife Nasreen, and their two daughters, Ayesha and Zaineb.
Zinc phosphide has no antidote. Here is exactly what it does to the body, and why even the best hospitals struggle to save a victim.
WHAT IS ZINC PHOSPHIDE, AND WHERE DOES IT COME FROM?
Zinc phosphide (Zn3P2) is a chemical compound widely used in rat poison in India. On its own, the powder is relatively stable. The danger begins the moment it enters the human stomach.
Your stomach contains hydrochloric acid, the same acid that breaks down food during digestion.
When zinc phosphide meets this acid, a chemical reaction is triggered. The reaction produces phosphine gas, a colourless, invisible gas that is extraordinarily toxic even in tiny amounts.
Food in the stomach makes things worse. Eating something like watermelon triggers even more acid production, which in turn releases even more phosphine gas.
On an empty stomach, symptoms may take up to 12 hours to appear. After a meal, they can arrive within minutes.
HOW DOES PHOSPHINE GAS ACTUALLY KILL YOU?
The gas does not simply poison the blood. It attacks your cells at their most basic level.
Inside every cell in your body are tiny structures called mitochondria or power houses of the cell. Think of them as miniature power stations.
Their job is to use oxygen in the process of respiration to produce energy to keep the cell alive and functioning.
Phosphine gas blocks a critical enzyme inside the mitochondria called Cytochrome C Oxidase.
Once this enzyme is blocked, your cells can no longer use oxygen, even if your lungs are working perfectly and even if you are on a hospital ventilator receiving pure oxygen.
The cells begin to die from the inside. This is called cellular anoxia, a state in which cells suffocate not because oxygen is absent, but because they have lost the ability to process it.
This is why the mortality rate for zinc phosphide poisoning is between 37 and 100 per cent.
IS THERE ANY ANTIDOTE FOR ZINC PHOSPHIDE POISONING?
No. There is no antidote in the world for zinc phosphide poisoning. Doctors cannot administer a drug that simply reverses its effects.
What they can do is try to slow down the release of phosphine gas and protect the organs from collapse.
One of the most important treatments is a stomach wash using coconut oil. Zinc phosphide does not dissolve in oil, so the coconut oil coats the powder particles and forms a physical barrier between the poison and the stomach acid, slowing the reaction.
Sodium bicarbonate, the compound found in ordinary baking soda, is used to reduce the stomach’s acidity, which further slows gas production.
Magnesium sulphate is given to protect the heart, because cardiac arrest is the leading cause of death in the first 24 hours.
Critically, a stomach wash using water is dangerous and can accelerate the release of phosphine gas rather than stop it.
This is the opposite of what most people would assume, and it is a trap that can turn well-meaning first aid into a fatal mistake.
HOW IS ZINC PHOSPHIDE DIFFERENT FROM OTHER RAT POISONS?
Most rat killers sold in India today are anticoagulants, which include chemicals such as bromadiolone that prevent blood from clotting and kill rodents over days or weeks.
These have an antidote: Vitamin K1. Zinc phosphide has no such counterpart. It kills in hours, leaves almost no window for treatment, and has baffled toxicologists for decades.
HOW DO DOCTORS AND FORENSIC EXPERTS IDENTIFY ZINC PHOSPHIDE POISONING?
The gas carries a distinct smell of garlic or rotting fish in the victim’s breath. This is caused by impurities present in the phosphine gas and is one of the first clues for emergency responders.
Because zinc is a heavy metal, it also appears as bright spots on an abdominal X-ray, giving forensic investigators a visual confirmation even when the patient is unconscious.
The Pydhonie case is a sobering reminder that one of the most dangerous substances in India is not locked behind a pharmacy counter.
It is sitting on a shelf in the kitchen.
– Ends